All things are known,but most things are forgotten.
It takes a special magic to remember them.

Robert Holdstock's Lavondyss

An addemdum to this piece which was orginally published by Green Man in early November of 2009.

Robert Holdstock passed away on the early morning hours of 29 November 2009. As his web mistress notes 'Rob was one of the best fantasy writers of his generation, and a man with a huge appetite for life. There was nothing he liked better than the company of good friends, a cracking meal, drink and laughter. His departure at only 61 years old is a tremendous loss.' He will be missed by all who knew him, either as just readers or as friends as well.

Ansible ran the best piece we've seen on him, 'Remembering Rob Holdstock, 1948 -- 2009', which you can read here.

As we are inclined to do from time to time, we're taking look at a specific work. This time we've chosen Avilion, the latest in Robert Holdstock's Ryhope Wood series -- now twenty-five years in the making since the appearance of the first novel, Mythago Wood.

So why Avilion now as my reading material? As you well know, late November is a cold, rainy, and often simply nasty time as regards the weather 'ere in the place where the Green Man offices are located. This being the case I decided to read the Green Man Library copy of Avilion, the latest novel in the Ryhope Wood series. These tales seem born of the colder time of year even when the story is set in warmer months, and fiction with a strong seasonal feel to it -- such as Emma Bull's midsummer-set War for The Oaks -- is something I always enjoy. This series handles seasonal changes in its corner of Albion very well indeed.

But this is not a review of Avilion, as another staffer is doing that task for us. This is more of an appreciation of a series that started twenty-five years ago. Keep in mind that the Ryhope Wood series is not easy reading. The language Holdstock uses in this series is decidedly challenging, as you can read in this brief excerpt from the fourth chapter of Mythago Wood, the first novel of the series . . .

Wynne-Jones arrived after dawn. Walked together along the south track, checking the flux-drains for signs of mythago activity. Back to the house quite shortly after-no-one about, which suited my mood. A crisp, dry autumn day. Like last year, images of the Urscumug are strongest as the season changes . . . Perhaps he senses autumn, the dying of the green. He comes forward, and the oakwoods whisper to him. He must be close to genesis. Wynne-Jones thinks a further time of isolation needed, and it -- can't speak to her. Must do what is needed.

If you read these novels carefully, you'll be amazed how everything fits together quite seamlessly. Be warned -- the language herein is decidedly not what you find in most fantasy works! It is truly mythopoeic in nature, with a dense self-referentiality that requires its readers to pay attention not just to the narrative here as it unfolds, but to how that narrative relates to everything else in the Ryhope Wood series. The stories here are anything but linear in nature, as time, space, even the characters themselves change over and over again, so that what appears a certain way at one point will likely not appear the same way elsewhere in the metanarritve!

Now Holdstock says that Avilion is the sequel to Mythago Wood, so while you need not read the intervening works to grasp the full meaning of Avilion, you must read Mythago Wood first or it will make no sense at all. Oh, Lavondyss, The Hollowing, and Gate of Ivory, Gate of Horn -- not to mention a related Brittany set novel called Merlin's Wood -- are well worth reading after you've read these two. Indeed, the entire series could well keep you going for months this coming winter!

Before picking up Avilion, do heed the words of Richard Dansky who reviewed the series for us -- 'It's not that they're not good. On the contrary, they represent some of the finest work done in fantasy over the past two decades, and possibly longer. No, the difficulty lies in the content and structure of the series. Most fantasy slots neatly into the 'heroic' category with its attempt at epic, trundling merrily along the Campbellian path of the hero's journey. Plots are linear, armies march, kingdoms struggle against evil, and in the end it all comes right in book three or five or seven or nine. Not so in Ryhope.'

And heed also the comments of noted writer Christopher Golden who said in the Green Man Pub when I asked him what he thought of the series as he sat reading his copy of Avilion -- 'Mythago Wood had a huge impact on me. I read it early on and loved it, the inward journey into human myth and belief most of all. I've enjoyed all of the others as well, but my favorite work of Holdstock's is his extraordinary and lamentably out of print short story collection The Bone Forest.'

(Our Librarian assures me that The Bone Forest novella is now back in print in the UK as part of the recently re-published Merlin's Wood which includes also two short stories 'Earth and Stone' which about a man witnessing the creation of Newgrange in Ireland, and 'The Silvering' a tale of Selkies. You can order it here.)

I envy you for having the pleasure of reading this series for the very first time!

Green Man Review News is an email list for readers of Green Man Review. Each edition, we'll send out a brief précis of our current edition. This is an announcement-only list. To subscribe, send an email to this address, or go here. Green Man Review also posts its updates on Livejournal.

Entire Contents Copyright © 1993-2010, Green Man Review, a publication of East of the Sun and West of the Moon Publishing except where specifically noted. All Rights Reserved.

We have absolutely no commercial or corporate underwriters to meet the expenses of maintaining this site. We do not accept advertisements for our site and have no commercial (profit-making) intentions whatsoever.

All stories, songs, and other intellectual property hosted on the Green Man Review site as linked to here is done so with the explicit permission of the copyright holder. No re-use is allowed without the express written permission of the copyright holder.

A metafictional postscript -- all actual living beings referred to in the Green Man grand narrative have agreed to be there. Really. Truly. Confused? Just sit back and enjoy our stories within stories. And do keep in mind that opinions expressed in the metanarrative do not necessarily reflect the views of Green Man Review or that of Sun and West of the Moon Publishing. They might, they might not.

Any resemblance in Continuity to persons, places, or times of anyone or anywhere living or dead, is purely coincidental unless otherwise noted. Those who know differently are unlikely to admit their involvement.

All About GMR


Contact GMR

Reprinting Reviews



Want to be a Reviewer?

What GMR Reviews

Editorial Staff


Cat Eldridge

Managing Editor

Lisa Spangenberg

Book Reviews Editor

April Gutierrez

Culinary Reviews Editor

Joseph Thompson

Film and DVD Reviews Editor

Maria Nutick

Performance Reviews Editor

Chris Tuthill

Recorded Music Editor

David Kidney


Faith Cormier

Denise Dutton

Robert Tilendis

Continuity Writers

Camille Alexa

Kate Bartholomew

Faith Cormier

Zina Lee

Jack Merry

Joseph Thompson

Robert Tilendis

Proofers and What's New Writers

Camille Alexa

Faith Cormier

Michael Jones

Iain Mackenzie

Robert Tilendis

Joseph Thompson

Matthew Winslow

Leona Wisoker

Author Editions

Kage Baker (1952 to 2010)

Peter S. Beagle

Elizabeth Bear

Stephen Brust

Charles de Lint

The Frouds

Neil Gaiman

Christopher Golden

Elizabeth Hand

Patricia McKillip

J.R.R. Tolkien (1892 to 1973)

Catherynne Valente

Other Editions

Best Music Reviewed!

Best of the Past Year

Bill Willingham's Fables series

Best Celtic Music

Folktales the Green Man staff loves

Nordic Music


Robert Holdstock's Ryhope Wood series

Series Reading

Steeleye Span

Summer libations

Terri Windling's Bordertown series

Winter libations

YBFH anthologies

Words and Music

Kage Baker reading her
The Empress of Mars

A reading from Peter S. Beagle's The Last Unicorn

Peter S. Beagle reading 'The Fifth Season', 'Marty and the Messenger', 'Mr. McCaslin', 'None But A Harper (Ibid.)', 'The Rock in the Park' and 'The Stickball Witch'

Excerpts from Peter S. Beagle's forthcoming novels, Here Be Dragons and Summerlong

Elizabeth Bear reads The Chains that You Refuse

Black 47's 'Liverpool Fantasy'

An excerpt from Paul Brandon's The Wild Reel novel

Tunes from Paul Brandon's old group, Rambling House and his new group, Sunas

Emma Bull and Will Shetterly's The War for The Oaks movie trailer

Nicholas Burbridge's 'Open House'

Cats Laughing's 'For It All'

Charles de Lint performing his 'Sam's Song'

Charles de Lint -- Some thoughts on his fiction

Gaelic Storm's 'Kiss Me'

Christopher Golden's 'The Deal'

The opening chapter of The Weaver and The Factory Maid, the first novel in Deborah Grabien's Haunted Ballad series.

An excerpt from Deborah Grabien's Rock & Roll Never Forgets -- A JP Kinkaid Mystery

'The Oak King March' (featuring Will Harmon and Zina Lee on fiddles and Pete Strickler on bouzouki), composed in honour of Peter S. Beagle

'The Winter Queen Reel' (played by Roger Landres), composed in honour of Jane Yolen

Chuck Lipsig on 'Star of Munster' variations

McDermott's 2 Hours' 'Fox on the Run'

Jennifer Stevenson's 'Solstice', plus a reading of 'Solstice' by Stevenson herself.

An excerpt from James Stoddard's 'The High House'

Tinker's Own performing 'The Tinker's Black Kettle', a jig by Charles de Lint from The Little Country

Vagabond Opera's 'Marlehe'

A Vasen tune for your enjoyment

Cathrynne Valente's 'The Surgeon's Wife'

Cathrynne Valente reading a selection titled 'The Tea Maid and The Tailor' from The Orphan's Tales

Robin Williamson's 'Five Denials on Merlin's Grave'


Kage Baker

Peter S. Beagle

Steven Brust

Emma Bull and Emma Bull & Will Shetterly on the War for the Oaks screenplay

Tom Canty

Glen Cook

Ellen Datlow and Gavin Grant of YBFH

Charles de Lint in 1998 and 2006

Gardner Dozois

Brian, Wendy and Toby Froud

Neil Gaiman in 2004 and 2005

William Gibson

Christopher Golden

James Hetley

Michael Kaluta

Patricia McKillip

James Stoddard

Catherynne Valente

Gordon Van Gelder

Charles Vess

Terri Windling


Uploaded 23 January 2010 1o -- 00 pm PST